Quote of the Day: The Journey by Mary Oliver
One day you finally knew
what you had to do, and began,
though the voices around you
kept shouting
their bad advice–
though the whole house
began to tremble
and you felt the old tug
at your ankles.
“Mend my life!”
each voice cried.
But you didn’t stop.
You knew what you had to do,
though the wind pried
with its stiff fingers
at the very foundations,
though their melancholy
was terrible.
It was already late
enough, and a wild night,
and the road full of fallen
branches and stones.
But little by little,
as you left their voices behind,
the stars began to burn
through the sheets of clouds,
and there was a new voice
which you slowly
recognized as your own,
that kept you company
as you strode deeper and deeper
into the world,
determined to do
the only thing you could do–
determined to save
the only life you could save.
This is the kitchen table in the founders house at Boyd’s Mills where I attended the Highlights workshop. The very first morning, I spent some time here alone, but I didn’t feel like I was alone. My best writer-mama-pal Roxane is a night owl who sleeps in. Ashley, who flew in the same day from Utah, was also easing into the morning, probably feeling like she was in a different time zone.
I sat at this table in a place where so many creative spirits have passed and felt the energy of inspiration. I drank my coffee, wrote in my journal, and gazed out at the beautiful trees and flowing stream. So much of life happens around the kitchen table. An apple rolled off the fruit bowl. I said, “No thanks, I’ll have this plumb instead,” to no one but the spirits.
The setting of the first chapter of my novel is a farm kitchen in 1941. A farm girl is there, doing all the work, like all the farm girls I’ve ever known. My story was the first to receive critique at the workshop. It went okay until one participant attacked it like an editor from New York. I felt like she was yelling at me, saying “Don’t you know that it’s wrong to put YA girls in the kitchen. And, there she sits for pages and pages.” I felt like an idiot for not knowing that rule, for making such an enormous blunder. Her blunt words stopped me in my tracks.
Then, I processed it internally and aloud with a few safe people. Here’s the thing, telling me I can’t put a 1940’s farm girl in the kitchen is like telling me I can’t put a sailor on a ship. Where else would she be? And, besides, so much life happens in the kitchen, at the table, surrounded by food and drink and conversations that don’t happen in any other room.
So, I decided that the title of the play I’ll be writing during April’s Scriptfrenzy is Kitchen Table Confessions. The only set I’ll need is a kitchen table.
The moral of this story is, Don’t let others and their opinions control you or your art. You are the only one designed to create what is on your heart. If you’ve been a people pleaser with low self-confidence, like me, this will take some practice. I have erroneously measured my self-worth, my work, my art, my everything by what others have said, their reactions. That needs to stop.
I resolve to no longer be controlled by others words, opinions, rules, or insecurities. Yes, I mean their insecurities. It is the very people who try to control you, who fear loss of control in themselves and are unable to be vulnerable and real. Your courage, your honesty, your unique creative spirit might be threatening them. Go on and do it anyway. We all need a challenge. And, that’s what it means to be your authentic self.
Go. Create. Inspire!
Journaling Prompt: Who or what has controlled you? Is a person? An opinion or way of life? Is it an unattainable body image or social status? Write it out, then let it go.
All I can say is…wow…this post really speaks to me. I am sorry you went through that experience with the harsh criticism you received, yet it seems you pulled something valuable from it. Even with poetry, I find that there are some people who are convinced that a poem has to sound a certain way, all of these rules, avoiding cliches, etc., yet when it comes down to it, it’s our opinion of our work that matters most. While critiques can be helpful at times, we must not lose ourselves.
There is a hard decision that had to be made in my house this week. Some parties were not happy, but ultimately we are at peace regarding our decision and that’s all that matters in the end. :O)
Yes, you are right and we need to trust our creative instinct above all. You should read A Northern Light by Jennifer Donnelly (sp?)…it won a Printz years ago and is a YA book about a girl on a farm and in the kitchen quite a bit. Wonderful, wonderful read.
good luck on your play…that’s impressive!
I love the idea of a story unfolding at the kitchen table, what better place! So much of life happens there, is talked about there, is considered over a cup of coffee, is decided upon at a meal. Go for it!
Holy powerful posts, Mary! The poem is beautiful and powerful and pierced my heart. The whole post pierced my heart – but in a good way. I am going to print this and save it for the days I feel full of doubt and uncertainty. Thank you.
There are always people who repeat like parrots certain “rules” which may or may not exist. I certainly never heard that one and I can single out a number of books which break it. It’s even worse when you internalize the rules and start in on your own writing.
I’ve often thought that I can take criticism but I can’t take misplaced “advice” which doesn’t seem to grasp what I was trying to do in the first place.
Amen Mary! Go on and do “You”. I love the idea of the farm girl in the kitchen, sitting for hours: So be it. The finished product will be nothing short of amazing…
Shine on!
Clara.
Love what Laura said, Mary! So true. The ‘rule-governed’ live in their own prisons. Having sat through that with you, I know your pain…and I understand why this would paralyze you. I’ve been stuck myself, but for now, I resolve to be grateful for my words and ideas. And to honor the ability to get them down on the page. Let’s look beyond all that, remember the beauty of the place, the weekend, and at Rich’s guidance and the wonderful bond we’ve forged! Onward and upward in 2011! (Sounds like a campaign slogan, right?) Let’s set some goals and let it go.
Good for you!
I am a farm girl and, yes, a lot goes on in the kitchen, when we’re not working outside.
Many problems have been solved, stories told, lives changed, friends made…all around the kitchen table.
Write!
I like the idea of Kitchen Table Confessions!
And I also agree with you, Mary, that while there are some things about craft that we all need to learn, some of the “rules” people create are not valid, and the best thing you can do is push back against them.
Sometimes the cruel…fuels. You are on fire, girl. Look at that poem and I love your kitchen scene. Is that really a rule not to put girls in the kitchen in 1940? Whaaat?
Thanks for the inspiration.
Mary, you know I’m behind you here. I’m still chuckling over your talking to the fruit spirits. 🙂 I’m glad you had that moment, even as I slept and snored. Thanks for understanding that about me. 🙂
Oh, am I glad I stopped by today! I would have missed this gem of a post. I can sense your fortitude, your confidence, coming forward, claiming your rightful place in the world as a creator, a nurturer, an artist. And I can’t wait to read “Kitchen Table Confessions!”
By the way, Mary Oliver never ceases to move me. Another Mary I love! 🙂
I like the title and I’m sure great stories will be told – your way:)
Wow! What a powerful post!
Of course a 1941 farm girl spent long hours in the kitchen. Revisionism doesn’t change what was (one of my hot buttons). I attended a writer’s confab once where this high-priced editor from a top dog NY agency spoke.
She went on and on about a children’s book to be released. Well, the setting was NYC, and, to be honest, I was totally clueless about what she was talking about. As was, come to find out during break, most of the room. No one could relate to the picky localisms common to NYC.
Now, a kitchen setting I can relate to. A farm setting I can relate to. Write on, Girl!
Obviously the New York type has never been to rural Minnesota..the kitchen table is the center, the very heart of a home.
I struggle with controlling people all the time..people who do not like my blog..I usually say fine don’t read then..it is really hard for me to deal with them. It takes so much of my energy:(
firt of all, Kitchen Table Confessions? WHAT A GREAT TITLE!!! I’m all about a great title! And secondly, NO, do not let others control you OR YOUR ART! Wisdom to live by! Luck and blessings with your writing,this year, Mary!